Skip to content
Transcendence DirectoryKnowledge Graph

Entity · Pillar 4: Secular Liminality & Rites of Passage

Mircea Eliade

Classification
Historian of religions (1907–1986); author of The Sacred and the Profane and Rites and Symbols of Initiation
Acquisition vector
Comparative history and phenomenology of religion
Retention loop
Continued citation of the sacred–profane distinction, sacred time and space, and initiation; continuing debate over his method and his politics

Direct answer

Mircea Eliade (1907–1986) was a Romanian historian of religions who taught at the University of Chicago (Allen, Britannica). In The Sacred and the Profane (English, 1959) he described the sacred and profane as “two modes of being in the world”: the sacred breaks into ordinary space and time through hierophanies, its manifestations. Durkheim had already made the sacred–profane pair central to religion in 1912. Eliade’s method and his 1930s politics remain contested.

I. Intellectual Lineage & Institutional Background

According to Douglas Allen’s Britannica article, Eliade was born in Bucharest on March 9, 1907. He studied philosophy at the University of Bucharest, studied in Calcutta under the Sanskrit scholar Surendranath Dasgupta (1928–30), and earned a PhD in 1933 with a dissertation on techniques of Yoga. He became a well-known novelist in Romania in the 1930s and served as a cultural attaché in London (1940) and Lisbon (1941–45).

After the war he lived in Paris, where he wrote Patterns in Comparative Religion and The Myth of the Eternal Return (both 1949). From 1956–57 he taught at the University of Chicago, where he chaired the history of religions department until he retired in 1983. He founded the journal History of Religions (1961), edited The Encyclopedia of Religion (1987), and died in Chicago on April 22, 1986.

Political controversy. Since the late 1980s, much writing on Eliade has focused on his political writings and activity in 1930s Romania. Critics charge that he supported Romanian fascism and antisemitism and later hid this. Defenders accept that some of his writings were indefensible but argue that the charges are exaggerated and should not cancel his scholarly work (Allen, Britannica).

II. The Sacred and the Profane

The Sacred and the Profane: The Nature of Religion (1959, translated by Willard R. Trask) is one of Eliade’s popular books (Allen, Britannica). Its main ideas, in plain terms:

  • Two modes of being. Eliade describes the sacred and the profane as “two modes of being in the world” (Eliade, as quoted by Barth, 2013). The sacred is the extraordinary, which he related to Rudolf Otto’s idea of the holy as “wholly other.”
  • Hierophany. The sacred shows itself through ordinary things, such as a tree, a river or an animal. Eliade called this a hierophany (Allen, Britannica).
  • Sacred space. A temple or other consecrated place breaks into ordinary space and gives people a fixed point to orient around, which Eliade linked to the symbolism of a “center of the world” (Barth, 2013).
  • Sacred time. Festivals and rites repeat the events of origin myths. New Year rites, for example, renew time by repeating the act of creation (Barth, 2013).
  • The religious and the modern person. In Eliade’s account, people in traditional societies try to live as close as possible to the sacred, while modern secular life is largely desacralized but keeps traces of it (Barth, 2013).

Comparison with Durkheim. Durkheim had already made the opposition between sacred and profane central to his theory of religion in 1912 (Carls, IEP). For Durkheim the distinction is social: sacred and profane exist because a society treats things that way (Barth, 2013). Eliade instead argued for “the irreducibility of the sacred” and criticized attempts to reduce religion to psychological, social or economic causes (Allen, Britannica).

Ordinary (profane) space and time
        |
        v
Hierophany: the sacred appears through an ordinary thing
        |
        v
Sacred place or festival time, set apart and repeated

III. Criticism and Influence

Criticism of the method. Barth (2013) reviews the main critiques:

  • The anthropologist Edmund Leach rejected Eliade’s approach. He faulted unclear terms, selective and partly outdated sources, sweeping generalizations from other scholars’ field reports, and a style closer to theology than to research.
  • Other scholars, including John A. Saliba, Kurt Rudolph and Robert D. Baird, questioned whether an archaic “religious man” of the kind Eliade describes ever existed.
  • Jonathan Z. Smith, following Durkheim, treated sacred space as a social construction: a way of focusing attention, not a place where something wholly other appears.

Defenders, including his student and biographer Mac Linscott Ricketts, argued that many critiques misread him (Barth, 2013).

Influence. Eliade was one of the most influential scholars of religion of the twentieth century (Allen, Britannica). His terms (sacred and profane, hierophany, sacred time and sacred space) recur in many later books and articles (Barth, 2013). His 1956 Haskell Lectures, Birth and Rebirth (1958), later reissued as Rites and Symbols of Initiation, define initiation as a basic change in a person’s existential condition and connect his work to van Gennep’s study of rites of passage.

Relational knowledge graph

Outgoing edges

  • Authored by Eliade Rites and Symbols of Initiation · FrameworkEliade’s Rites and Symbols of InitiationEliade gave the 1956 Haskell Lectures published as Birth and Rebirth (1958), later Rites and Symbols of Initiation.
  • Explained by rites of passage · FrameworkVan Gennep’s Rites of PassageEliade’s initiation account concerns the transition rites van Gennep (1909) classified.

← Back to the Transcendence Directory

Editorial Notice: Entry in this directory represents academic, neuro-somatic, and sociological classification based on peer-reviewed literature and does not constitute a legal finding or medical diagnosis. Corrections:geniustolife@gmail.com