Framework · Pillar 4: Secular Liminality & Rites of Passage
Wood’s Antistructure and the Roots of Religious Experience (2020)
- Classification
- Neo-Durkheimian research framework for religiously interpreted altered states of consciousness
- Acquisition vector
- Theoretical synthesis of anthropology, cognitive neuroscience, and philosophy of institutions
- Retention loop
- Testable predictions about synchrony, social prediction, and institutional roles
Direct answer
Wood’s antistructure framework is a proposal by Connor Wood (“Antistructure and the Roots of Religious Experience,” Zygon: Journal of Religion and Science 55(1), 2020, pp. 125–156) for studying religiously interpreted altered states of consciousness, which he calls “religious ASCs.” Building on Victor Turner’s antistructure, Wood argues that antistructural ritual “shifts cognitive focus away from conventional affordances, collective intentionality, and social prediction, and toward physical affordances and behavioral motivations that make few references to others’ intentional states” (p. 125). His paradigm cases are trances induced by drumming and dance. The article is a theoretical synthesis with testable predictions; it reports no new data.
I. Core Claim: Structure, Antistructure, and Conventional Affordances
Wood starts from a gap he sees in the cognitive and evolutionary sciences of religion (CESR): they have a standard model of religious representations but no agreed way to study religious experience. He quotes Justin Barrett (2011, 231) as concluding that “religious experiences currently fall outside the purview of” the field (as quoted in Wood, 2020, p. 126). Against this, he offers “a neo-Durkheimian model of ritual as a social process (Turner [1969] 1996)” (p. 126).
Following Turner and Olaveson (2001), Wood defines antistructure as settings in which “(1) normal social roles and rules are temporarily voided; (2) structural hierarchies are flattened or inverted; and/or (3) symbolic or socially constructed boundaries are abrogated” (p. 126). His central claim (p. 127) is that antistructure shifts participants’ focus “away from the conventional affordances that define everyday interactions and which depend on collective intentionality and norms,” and “toward physical affordances or data that are not conventional and which therefore motivate behavior directly—that is, without explicit reference to the intentional states of co-actors.”
His worked example is a Korean shamanic kut. In everyday Confucian life, a young wife and her father-in-law follow role-templated scripts that require predicting each other’s intentions. During the ceremony, “loud, rhythmically banging drums and perhaps alcohol downregulate complex social prediction while sometimes producing trance and/or spirit possession” (p. 127), so that behavior is coordinated “through basic physiological channels, reducing the salience of collective intentions” (p. 127). Wood notes that such ceremonies are still “carefully orchestrated, generally led by expert specialists, and tightly constrained to particular places and times” (p. 139).
Wood frames this with Durkheim’s homo duplex: “the individual organism with its intrinsic drives and motives, juxtaposed with a social entity straining to meet its externally imposed obligations” (p. 135). In ecstatic trance, he writes, “participants are paradoxically closest to the organismic, not the social, pole of Durkheim’s homo duplex (Olaveson 2001)” (p. 140). He says the framework explains three recurring features of profound religious experience: “their apparent undeniability (James [1902] 1982), their association with gross physiological states (Bakhtin [1984] 2009), and their susceptibility to manipulative interventions such as drug use or rhythmic music (Olaveson 2001)” (p. 131).
II. Proposed Neural Pathway and the Studies Wood Cites
Wood starts with pleasure: rhythmic synchrony “is pleasurable. More importantly: it is intrinsically pleasurable” (p. 137). He then argues that social cognition involves effortfully suppressing the urge to mimic, so that collective dance allows “the spontaneous urge to imitate—to finally express itself unimpeded” (p. 138).
His neural argument (p. 140) proceeds in steps, each tied to a cited study:
| Step in Wood’s argument (pp. 138–141) | Study cited | What that study reports (as read for this page) |
|---|---|---|
| Complementary actions activate parts of the TPJ; identical actions downregulate it | Newman-Norlund et al. (2007) | Abstract: BOLD in right inferior frontal gyrus and bilateral inferior parietal lobes greater when preparing complementary than imitative actions |
| Synchrony with a predictable rhythm goes with “quiescence in the TPJ and related areas of the social cognition network” | Fairhurst et al. (2013); Cacioppo et al. (2014) | Mixed; see the mechanism page. Cacioppo et al. found some regions more active during synchrony |
| dmPFC is downregulated with an optimally adaptive partner, active when struggling with an out-of-step rhythm | Fairhurst et al. (2013); Cacioppo et al. (2014) | Broadly consistent: dmPFC activity tracked difficulty or perceived asynchrony |
| Synchrony raises generosity toward in-groups and out-groups alike | Reddish et al. (2014) | Abstract: “initial support” for generalized prosociality |
| Rhythm-induced trance activates internal-state networks and decouples sensory input | Hove et al. (2016) | Full text: stronger PCC hub and reduced auditory-pathway connectivity in experienced practitioners |
From these he concludes that, “within a predictive processing framework, this quiescence of the social-cognitive network is likely due to a reduced need for complex social prediction during rhythmic synchrony” (p. 140), and that “self-transcendence in ecstatic dance thus appears to be transcendence over our institutional selves” (p. 141). He also flags a contrast: in many forms of meditation, TPJ recruitment “is intensified compared to baseline” (p. 141).
III. Predictions, Open Questions, and Limits
Wood states that “an interpretive framework is only as useful as its ability to generate testable, empirical predictions” (p. 143), and lists four (pp. 143–144):
- After rhythmic synchrony, people may “attribute less legitimacy to institutional propositions such as ‘wives owe their fathers-in-law filial piety,’ or may simply require longer processing times to assess such propositions.”
- People who watch others move in synchrony should attribute less salience to their differentiated roles and see “a flat social structure” among them.
- If synchrony flattens structure, it should hurt coordination that needs a division of labor. He notes that earlier research “has hinted that synchrony can indeed hamper interdependent coordination (Lang et al. 2016; Wood, Caldwell-Harris, and Stopa 2018), but more robust study designs are needed.” In that 2018 study, groups in the synchrony condition “performed more poorly on the coordination exercise and reported higher levels of conflict as well as lower levels of group cohesion and similarity,” which the authors read as “boundary conditions on the prosocial effects of synchrony” (Wood et al., 2018, abstract).
- Ecstatic religion may let social hierarchies change when they “chronically fail to provide utility” (p. 144).
His open questions (p. 145) include how subdued synchrony such as marching (McNeill, 1995) differs from ecstatic synchrony; whether the superior parietal downregulation Newberg and d’Aquili reported in meditation, a “different cortical network,” could falsify his central prediction; and why, “if social cognition is truly downregulated during religious ASCs,” so many such states feature interactions with gods or spirits. A note records that “my lab is currently testing several of these predictions” (p. 149, n. 4).
Limits. The article reviews and connects existing studies; it does not report new data. Several steps rest on small fMRI samples, and some of the cited findings are mixed when read in the original papers (see the mechanism page and the linked metric pages). Tarr et al. (2015), whom Wood also cites, found no synchrony effect on out-group bonding, which tempers the Reddish et al. (2014) reading. Wood acknowledges a John Templeton Foundation grant (No. 61157).
Relational knowledge graph
Outgoing edges
- Authored by Connor Wood · EntityConnor Wood is the sole author of “Antistructure and the Roots of Religious Experience,” Zygon 55(1), 2020, pp. 125–156.
- Explained by Victor Turner liminality · FrameworkTurnerian Liminality, Anti-Structure, and CommunitasWood takes the term “antistructure” from Turner ([1969] 1996) and describes his proposal as a research framework that “picks up where Turner ([1969] 1996; 1975) left off” (p. 146).
- Explained by Olaveson 2001 · FrameworkOlaveson’s Collective Effervescence and Communitas (2001)Wood cites Olaveson (2001) for his definition of antistructure (p. 126), for ecstatic trance being closest to the “organismic, not the social, pole” of homo duplex (p. 140), and for susceptibility to manipulation (p. 131).
- Explained by Émile Durkheim · EntityWood calls the framework “neo-Durkheimian” (p. 125) and builds on Durkheim’s homo duplex, the organism with its own drives set against a social entity meeting “externally imposed obligations” (p. 135).
- Explained by shared intentionality · MechanismShared Intentionality (Tomasello et al., 2005)Wood’s “conventional affordances” depend on “collective intentionality and norms” (p. 127). He cites Tomasello’s A Natural History of Human Morality (2016), a later work than Tomasello et al. (2005).
- Explained by social prediction downregulation · MechanismSocial-Prediction Quiescence During Rhythmic Synchrony (Wood, 2020)The framework’s proposed neural pathway: rhythmic synchrony quiets social-cognition and social-prediction networks (pp. 140–141).
- Is induced by rhythmic auditory driving · Induction VectorRhythmic Auditory Driving and Acoustic EntrainmentWood treats “trances produced via synchrony (drumming and dance)” as his paradigm case (p. 127) and cites repetitive drumming (Hove et al., 2016) among standard means of inducing religious ASCs (p. 143).
- Measured by Hove 2016 shamanic trance fMRI · Empirical MetricNetwork Reconfiguration in Drumming-Induced Shamanic Trance (Hove et al., 2016)Wood cites Hove et al. (2016) for internal-state networks being activated and sensory input being “decoupled from conscious processing while continuing to inform motor behavior” during rhythm-induced trance (p. 138).
- Measured by Reddish synchrony prosociality · Empirical MetricGeneralized Prosociality After Synchrony (Reddish, Bulbulia & Fischer, 2014)Wood cites Reddish, Bulbulia & Fischer (2014) for synchrony making participants more generous toward in-groups and out-groups alike (p. 141).
- Measured by Tarr 2015 dance synchrony · Empirical MetricPain Threshold and Bonding After Synchronized, Exertive Dance (Tarr et al., 2015)Wood cites Tarr et al. (2015) for synchrony and exertion each increasing bonding and pain tolerance, and asks what effects they might have on processing of institutional norms (p. 145).
- Explained by muscular bonding · MechanismMuscular Bonding Through Keeping Together in Time (McNeill, 1995)Open question in Wood (p. 145): how does “subdued or low-expressiveness synchrony (such as marching in cadence; McNeill 1995)” differ from ecstatic synchrony?
- Explained by holistic operator parietal lobe · MechanismParietal Holistic Operator and Self–World Boundary DissolutionWood says Newberg and d’Aquili’s superior parietal findings involve “a different cortical network than the social cognition circuit” and that the contrast may allow “falsifying” a central prediction of his framework (p. 145). A proposed test.
- Explained by four marks of mystical experience · FrameworkJames’s Four Marks of Mystical States (1902)Wood lists “apparent undeniability (James [1902] 1982)” among recurring features his framework explains (p. 131), glossing it as the sense that a religious experience is “mandatorily self-evident” (p. 142). Wood’s reading of James.
- Explained by focused attention meditation · Induction VectorFocused-Attention and Related Mindfulness MeditationContrast drawn by Wood (p. 141): in many forms of meditation, temporoparietal-junction recruitment “is intensified compared to baseline,” unlike his proposal for synchrony.
Reciprocal links (resolved at build)
- Explains Andrew Newberg · EntityAndrew B. NewbergWood (2020) cites Newberg, d’Aquili & Rause (2002) for superior parietal downregulation in meditation and treats it as a different network from the one his framework concerns; he proposes the contrast as a test (p. 145).
- Explains Eugene d'Aquili · EntityEugene G. d’AquiliWood (2020) writes that Newberg and d’Aquili’s neuroimaging studies “largely lack social-scientific interpretation” (p. 130) and contrasts their parietal findings with his social-prediction account (p. 145).
- Explains Michael Tomasello · EntityWood (2020) draws on Tomasello (2016, 2019) for collective intentionality and the prediction of role-based behavior in everyday interaction.
- Explains DRH New Religiosity Poll · Empirical MetricNew Religiosity and the Digital Study of Eudaimonia (DRH New Religiosity Poll, JTF Grant #63357)Wood (2020) models how antistructural group settings modulate institutional norms and social prediction; the New Religiosity Poll documents observable group practices, wellbeing indicators, and lifestyle structures across contemporary movements.
- Explains William H. McNeill · EntityWood (2020) cites McNeill’s Keeping Together in Time (1995) for marching in cadence as subdued synchrony.
← Back to the Transcendence Directory
Editorial Notice: Entry in this directory represents academic, neuro-somatic, and sociological classification based on peer-reviewed literature and does not constitute a legal finding or medical diagnosis. Corrections:geniustolife@gmail.com