Framework · Pillar 5: Non-Dogmatic Ego Dissolution & Secular Self-Transcendence
Keltner & Haidt’s Prototype Approach to Awe (2003)
- Classification
- Prototype theory of awe: two central appraisals plus five flavouring themes
- Acquisition vector
- Conceptual review of religious, philosophical, sociological and psychological writing on awe
- Retention loop
- Basis for later awe measures and experiments (Shiota et al., 2007; Piff et al., 2015; AWE-S)
Direct answer
Keltner & Haidt’s prototype approach to awe (Cognition and Emotion 17(2), 2003, pp. 297–314) proposes that “two appraisals are central and are present in all clear cases of awe: perceived vastness, and a need for accommodation, defined as an inability to assimilate an experience into current mental structures.” Five further appraisals (threat, beauty, exceptional ability, virtue, and the supernatural) change the tone of an awe experience. The authors note they built the account “in the absence of empirical evidence” and end with proposals for testing it.
I. Central Appraisals
The paper sets out a prototype: a core shared by clear cases of awe, with variants around it. The two central appraisals are:
- Perceived vastness: anything experienced as much larger than the self or its ordinary frame of reference. Vastness may be physical, or social (fame, authority), or conceptual (a grand theory).
- Need for accommodation: in Piaget’s sense, the experience cannot be fitted into existing mental structures, so the structures must change.
The pairing explains near neighbours. In the authors’ analysis, surprise involves accommodation without vastness, while deference to a powerful person involves vastness without accommodation.
II. Flavouring Themes and Elicitors
Five additional appraisals “account for variation in the hedonic tone of awe experiences: threat, beauty, exceptional ability, virtue, and the supernatural.” Threat produces awe tinged with fear; beauty yields aesthetic awe; ability and virtue shade into admiration and elevation.
The paper’s table of eliciting situations runs from social elicitors (a powerful leader, an encounter with God, great skill, great virtue) through physical ones (a tornado, a grand vista, a cathedral, awe-inspiring music, a painting) to cognitive ones: a grand theory, and seeing an object levitate (marked as uncanny). The text extends the cognitive case to epiphanies.
The authors distinguish primordial awe, which they place in a subordinate’s response to a powerful leader, from culturally elaborated forms. They suggest primordial awe may help reinforce social hierarchies, drawing on Weber and Durkheim, and that elaborated awe extends to nature, art, and religion.
III. Status, Tests, and Later Work
Keltner & Haidt state that they developed the approach “with some trepidation, in the absence of empirical evidence,” and close with proposals for research. They mention goosebumps as a possible physical marker and suggest awe can reorient a person’s life. These were hypotheses in 2003.
Later studies tested parts of the account. Shiota, Keltner & Mossman (2007, abstract) found that awe elicitors were largely information-focused and that awe was self-diminishing. Piff et al. (2015) linked awe to prosocial behavior through a “small self.” The Awe Experience Scale (Yaden et al., 2018) includes perceived vastness and need for accommodation as two of its six factors.
Relational knowledge graph
Outgoing edges
- Authored by Dacher Keltner · EntityDacher Keltner is first author of “Approaching awe, a moral, spiritual, and aesthetic emotion” (Cognition and Emotion, 2003), with Jonathan Haidt.
- Explained by Émile Durkheim · EntityKeltner & Haidt draw on Durkheim’s account of powerful collective emotions in political, social and religious movements.
- Explained by peak experience · MechanismPeak Experiences (Maslow)The paper reviews Maslow’s 25 features of peak experiences, including ego transcendence and self-forgetfulness, as earlier work bearing on awe.
- Explained by Abraham Maslow · EntityAbraham H. MaslowMaslow (1964) is one of the psychological sources Keltner & Haidt review.
- Explained by small self · MechanismAwe, the Small Self, and Prosocial Behavior (Piff et al., 2015)Piff et al. (2015) build their small-self hypothesis on this account of awe as a response to vastness that calls for accommodation.
- Measured by Awe Experience Scale · Empirical MetricAwe Experience Scale (AWE-S)The AWE-S was built on the definition of awe as “an appraisal of vastness and a need for accommodation” (Yaden et al., 2018, abstract); both appraisals are factors of the scale.
- Manifests in awe definition · MechanismAwe: Definition and ScienceOverview of awe that starts from this paper’s two central appraisals, vastness and need for accommodation, and adds later findings on the self, physiology and health.
Reciprocal links (resolved at build)
- Explains self-transcendent experience · FrameworkThe Varieties of Self-Transcendent Experience (Yaden et al., 2017)Awe is one of the self-transcendent positive emotions in the review; Keltner & Haidt’s vastness-and-accommodation account is its reference point.
← Back to the Transcendence Directory
Editorial Notice: Entry in this directory represents academic, neuro-somatic, and sociological classification based on peer-reviewed literature and does not constitute a legal finding or medical diagnosis. Corrections:geniustolife@gmail.com