Framework · Pillar 5: Non-Dogmatic Ego Dissolution & Secular Self-Transcendence
The Varieties of Self-Transcendent Experience (Yaden et al., 2017)
- Classification
- Integrative review and organizing framework for self-transcendent experiences (STEs)
- Acquisition vector
- Review of psychology, religious studies and affective neuroscience literatures on self-loss and unity
- Retention loop
- Widely used definition of self-transcendent experience, adopted by later measurement reviews
Direct answer
Self-transcendent experiences (STEs), as defined by Yaden, Haidt, Hood, Vago & Newberg (2017, Review of General Psychology 21(2), 143–160), are “transient mental states marked by decreased self-salience and increased feelings of connectedness.” The review groups mindfulness, flow, peak experiences, mystical-type experiences, and some positive emotions (such as love and awe) under this heading. It splits STEs into an annihilational component (fading sense of a bounded self) and a relational component (connection to people and surroundings), and places them on a spectrum of intensity.
I. Definition, Components, and Scope
The authors define STEs as “transient mental states marked by decreased self-salience and increased feelings of connectedness.” They describe two subcomponents: “(a) reduced self-salience—fading bodily and social boundaries” (the “annihilational component”) and “(b) connection to other people and things in the environment beyond the self” (the “relational component”). The two usually come together, but the authors treat them as separable; they suggest, without having tested it, that depersonalization may involve the first without the second.
STEs are placed on a spectrum of intensity, from the routine (being lost in music or a book) to rare, intense unity experiences, a range that “has been called the unitary continuum (Newberg & d’Aquili, 2000).” The constructs reviewed are mindfulness, flow, self-transcendent positive emotions (including awe, elevation, gratitude and love), peak experiences, and mystical-type experiences.
The authors report that STEs remain common, “with around one third of people in samples from multiple cultures reporting intense experiences of unity with other people and their surroundings (Hood, Hill, & Spilka, 2009, pp. 343–347).” On mental health they conclude that “Freud was wrong and James was right regarding the positive psychological potential of STEs,” a qualified consensus in their reading.
II. Candidate Mechanisms
| Proposed basis | What the review says | Strength as the authors present it |
|---|---|---|
| Parietal and temporoparietal regions | Decreased superior parietal activity in meditators and nuns reporting unity (Newberg et al., 2001, SPECT); the regions model bodily position in space | Imaging convergence on candidate regions |
| Self/other networks | Shared brain systems for representing self and others might allow self/other overlap | “While speculative” |
| Oxytocin and vasopressin | Associated with perceived social connection, “though the magnitude of this effect and how wide the scope of this social connection extends are the subject of ongoing debate” | Candidate only |
| Vagal tone | The vagus nerve is active during self-transcendent emotions such as awe, compassion and gratitude | Candidate only |
The review presents these as candidates for future work. A later methods review (Kitson et al., 2020) adds that the neuropeptide research “is based on animal models.”
III. Evolutionary Questions and Limits
The authors ask whether the capacity for STEs is an adaptation or a “spandrel,” a byproduct of other evolved traits. They doubt individual-level selection; benefits to individuals are “highly speculative.” Benefits to groups “are easier to trace”: STEs often foster trust and cohesion. They describe Haidt’s (2012) “Hive Hypothesis,” in which STEs “may have emerged originally as spandrels or neurological accidents” but then gave an advantage to groups whose rituals and worship harnessed them. Whether any such group-level process was purely cultural or also affected genes “cannot be known at present.”
Limits. This is an integrative review and organizing framework, not a test. Many mechanism claims rest on small imaging studies or on correlational and animal research. The article was read in its online-first author copy; page numbers are therefore not given here.
Relational knowledge graph
Outgoing edges
- Authored by David B. Yaden · EntityDavid B. Yaden is first author of “The Varieties of Self-Transcendent Experience” (Review of General Psychology, 2017).
- Authored by Andrew Newberg · EntityAndrew B. NewbergAndrew B. Newberg is the fifth author of the 2017 review (Yaden, Haidt, Hood, Vago & Newberg).
- Explained by ego dissolution definition · MechanismEgo Dissolution as Compromised Self-ReferenceThe review’s “annihilational component,” reduced self-salience with fading bodily and social boundaries, overlaps with ego dissolution.
- Measured by Inclusion of Other in the Self scale · Empirical MetricInclusion of Other in the Self ScaleThe review uses the Inclusion of Other in Self Scale as a figure for the continuous nature of feelings of unity (the relational component).
- Explained by Csikszentmihalyi flow theory · FrameworkCsikszentmihalyi’s Flow TheoryFlow is one of the constructs the review counts as having a self-transcendent aspect.
- Explained by peak experience · MechanismPeak Experiences (Maslow)Peak experiences are among the constructs the review includes as self-transcendent.
- Explained by four marks of mystical experience · FrameworkJames’s Four Marks of Mystical States (1902)The authors conclude that “on the whole, Freud was wrong and James was right regarding the positive psychological potential” of STEs.
- Explained by holistic operator parietal lobe · MechanismParietal Holistic Operator and Self–World Boundary DissolutionThe review cites decreased superior parietal activity in meditators and nuns reporting unity (Newberg et al., 2001) as a candidate basis for self-loss.
- Explained by Keltner Haidt awe · FrameworkKeltner & Haidt’s Prototype Approach to Awe (2003)Awe is one of the self-transcendent positive emotions in the review; Keltner & Haidt’s vastness-and-accommodation account is its reference point.
- Explained by Émile Durkheim · EntityIn the evolutionary section the authors trace group-level benefits of STEs through Durkheim’s account of collective ritual. Their framing.
Reciprocal links (resolved at build)
- Explains small self · MechanismAwe, the Small Self, and Prosocial Behavior (Piff et al., 2015)Awe is one of the self-transcendent emotions in Yaden et al.’s (2017) framework; the small self corresponds to its annihilational, self-diminishing side.
- Explains Kitson 2020 self-transcendence methods · FrameworkKitson et al.’s Review of Self-Transcendence Research Methods (2020)Kitson et al. take their working definition from Yaden et al. (2017): decreased self-saliency and increased connection to others and the environment.
- Explains NADA · Empirical MetricNondual Awareness Dimensional Assessment (NADA)NADA items are balanced between relational and annihilational self-transcendence, the two components named by Yaden et al. (2017).
- Explains group singing oxytocin · Empirical MetricSalivary Oxytocin and Cortisol After Group Singing (Bowling et al., 2022)Yaden et al. (2017) list oxytocin as a candidate basis of felt connection whose effect size is debated; these data show oxytocin falling, not rising, after group singing.
← Back to the Transcendence Directory
Editorial Notice: Entry in this directory represents academic, neuro-somatic, and sociological classification based on peer-reviewed literature and does not constitute a legal finding or medical diagnosis. Corrections:geniustolife@gmail.com